College Football Playoff Rankings
The College Football Playoff Committee has released their most recent rankings. This will come as a shock to absolutely no one, but people are finding reasons to be upset. Some are upset that Alabama is ranked higher than Tennessee, that Indiana dropped to 9, or that the SEC has 5 teams making the playoffs if the season ended today. I on the other hand, don’t really hate the rankings. I am of the mindset that everyone still has 3 games left to play, and that it will all get worked out in the end. I refuse to get upset until I see the final rankings.
For the people that are upset that Alabama is at 3 spots and Tennessee is at 8, I get it. Tennessee won a head to head and has the same record. I would say that I am not upset that Alabama is ahead of Tennessee, I am not upset that Alabama is at 3, but I do think that a 5 spot difference is a little high. If we look at each team’s record vs current top 25, Alabama has a slight edge. They’ve got wins over number 11, 17, and 21. Tennessee has wins over 3 and 11. Tennessee has better wins, Alabama has more wins over top 25. If you’re upset Alabama is 5 spots higher than Tennessee, I get it.
Indiana dropped from 4 to 9 while on a bye week. At first glance, that seems unfair. How can a team that didn’t even play this last week drop 5 spots? Let’s look at their schedule. They’ve faced 6 P4 teams. Every single one of those teams lost this last weekend, which makes Indiana’s wins of those teams less impressive the more they lose. If you wanna put on your tinfoil hat, Curt Cignetti’s comments about how ESPN, the network that has the rights to the college football playoff, favors SEC teams over Big Ten teams. One could argue that his comments rubbed the committee the wrong way which could have led to the drop.
Curt Cignetti criticizing the SEC leads perfectly into another reason people are upset, there are 5 SEC teams making the playoff if the season ended today. Now I will say again, there are still 3 weeks left in the season. A lot can change between now and then. Tennessee could lose to Texas A&M, LSU, or both. Kentucky could lose any one of their final 3 games, and Texas is always primed to lose games. The next 5 teams on the outside looking in currently are all Big 12, ACC, and Big Ten teams. Is it possible the SEC gets 5 teams in? Yes. Will they? We will see.
As for the rest of the top 25.
Anyone 12-25 has a shot to still make the playoff. Most, if not all, would have to win out. If Wake Forest drops another game, they are probably out. I do not think they get in as a 10-2 team. The same argument could be made for Iowa even if they win out. They would need some help in front of them to make it as a 10-2 team. I think we will see someone currently in the 12-20 range make the playoff.
This season has been full of surprises, and I don’t think they are ending anytime soon. The final 3 weeks are going to be exciting to watch. When you look at the playoff rankings, or the full top 25, what stands out? What did the committee get right? What did they get wrong? Who is a team in the 12-25 range that you think can make a run and make the playoff?
