Is the Big Ten’s Three Year Reign Over?
The story of this weekend is not how much trouble Oklahoma might be in, or how Texas might be back for real this time. The story is how the Big Ten is still struggling. There were 8 Big Ten vs Power 4 matchups this weekend, and they went 2-6 in those games. Washington beating Utah State 16-14 is just the cherry on top to a pitiful weekend for the Big Ten. This was an absolutely terrible look after a handful of teams looked mediocre in week 1 against lesser opponents. Let’s run through the teams that went up against Power 4 opponents. We will start on a good note.
Michigan 17 Oklahoma 10
Everyone and their mama was backing Oklahoma going into this one. That made me very nervous, but I still stood firm backing Oklahoma. Can you blame us? Did you watch that opening game vs Western Michigan. Turns out that maybe we can make the argument that Michigan was looking past Western Michigan to this game. This was a sloppy game that was dominated by both defenses. Bryce Underwood did just enough, while John Mateer struggled. Coming out of this game I realized a few things.
The first takeaway I had was that this is the exact same Oklahoma team from last season without the turnover luck. Last year Oklahoma made it all the to the College Football Playoff off the back of their defense and special teams. The offense had a myriad of problems that do not seem to be fixed. The offensive line was bad last year, the run game was non-existent, and John Mateer struggled. Saturday’s game vs Michigan looked exactly like last year, just without the defense forcing turnovers. Everything that I thought and hoped would be better for Oklahoma, didn’t look that way Saturday. Now all of those things were not great, but we also can’t ignore the fact that there was also a ton of sketchy play calling from Ben Arbuckle. Especially right before halftime, there were a few plays that left me scratching my head. If Oklahoma doesn’t turn it around on that side of the ball, I am real curious to see what happens with him.
My second takeaway is that Michigan could end up being this year’s Oklahoma. A team that is led by a phenomenal defense and special teams, that is accompanied by a lackluster offense. Michigan won this game, but it was thanks to the defense and Michigan’s offense doing the bare minimum. There were plays to be had against this Oklahoma defense, but they just didn’t quite hit them. If you take away Bryce Underwood’s rushing, the run game was brutal. Savion Hiter, Jordan Marshall, and Bryson Kuzdzal combined for 22 carries for 50 yards. That’s just over 2 yards per carry. The passing game was not much better as Underwood went 9/17 for 111 yards. The real MVP of this game was Punter Trey Butkowski, who not only once, but twice pinned Oklahoma inside their own 1 yard line. 6 of his 7 punts put Oklahoma inside their own 20. Special teams often gets overlooked, but when it’s elite, it’s game changing.
This was a great win for Michigan to right the ship after a brutal week 1. I still have a ton of worries surrounding this Michigan offense, but this defense is going to keep them in every game this season. As for Oklahoma, maybe they can repeat what they did last year? That would require a good amount of turnover luck against teams like Texas and Georgia. Much like Michigan, this defense will keep them in most games. There is still a path for them to win 9-10 games, but it will not be easy with Texas and Georgia coming up shortly.
Texas 24 Ohio State 23
As someone who had money on Texas to win outright, I thought it was over at halftime when Ohio State was up 20-3. Then I really thought it was over after the 3rd quarter when Ohio State lead 23-3. Finally in the 4th quarter Arch Manning and the Texas offense woke up. The offensive line started to get push, the run game started to explode, and the defense was able to shut down Ohio State’s offense.
This game could not have started any worse for Texas, and they were fighting from behind basically from snap one. 2 turnovers on the first 2 drives of the game is not the way you want to start against the number 1 team in the country. On top of the offense struggling, Jeremiah Smith was torching their defense. Going into halftime the Longhorn’s offense had less than 100 total yards compared to Ohio State’s 240. The Buckeyes could do no wrong. Then everything changed after halftime. It wasn’t immediate. It took most of the 3rd quarter before we saw the results, but slowly the offense for Texas figured it out, and the offense for Ohio State slowed down. I’m willing to say that this Texas comeback is the best comeback we will see all season. I know it’s only week 2 with a lot of season left, but if you watched the game, you know how dead this Texas team looked.
Obviously this was not ideal the way the game ended, but I wouldn’t be too concerned if I am an Ohio State fan. Your team dominated 3/4 of that game, they just couldn’t quite finish. If there was a concern to take away from this game, it’s that they need to find another option besides Jeremiah Smith. He went off for 8 receptions 164 yards and 1 touchdown. Everyone else combined for 9 receptions 114 yards and 0 touchdowns. Their 2nd leading receiver was Bo Jackson with 4, 37, and 0. Yes Jeremiah Smith is great and should have a statline like that every single week, but they need someone else to step up in big games. In the end I am nitpicking a little, Ohio State is still one of the best teams in the country
Oklahoma State 39 Oregon 31
Raise your hand if you saw this coming. No one? Yeah that sounds about right. Struggling week 1 vs Boise State wasn’t ideal, but you could talk yourself into it was just the first game of the season. Going on the road to play an Oklahoma State team that just lost to Tulsa the week before looked like an easy bounce back game for Oregon. It was not. Oregon’s offense did not look great. They themselves did not score until about 5 min left in the 1st half, and that came off an Oklahoma State turnover that put Oregon on the 1 yard line. The offensive line, which was was a question heading into the year, allowed 4 sacks. Dante Moore completed less than 50% of his passes, the Oregon receivers had too many drops, and the offense as a whole only managed 281 total yards. Not great.
The defense was not much better. Going into the year all we heard was how elite this defensive line was going to be. I even thought they would be one of the better d-lines in the country. They had 1 tackle for loss in this game against an offensive line that was out their starting LT. Outside those 2 turnovers in the 1st half, they could not stop this offense. Drew Mestemaker had over 400 yards himself and 3 touchdowns. Caleb Hawkins had over 100 yards on the ground and averaged nearly 5 yards a carry. It was a night and day difference from last week to this week for Oklahoma State offensively.
You look at this Oregon roster and see that this team has a ton of players that were here last year. A team that went 13-2. So you have a ton of players from that 13 win team, that can’t be the problem this year. You’ve got the same head coach, so that can’t be the problem either. The biggest difference between last year and this year is that they don’t have Tosh Lupoi or Will Stein. Turns out losing both playcallers may not be so easy to replace. Moving forward, this Oregon team is talented to win out the rest of the year. They are talented enough to make the College Football Playoff, and maybe even make a run at the title. Maybe this is the wake up call that they needed. We saw what happened to Alabama last year, they lost to FSU, and then went on a run the rest of the season. Oregon can do that same thing. I am not ready to write Oregon off yet, but I would be lying if I said I wasn’t a little concerned.
Mississippi State 38 Minnesota 13
Going into this game it would have been nice to know that Darius Taylor was hurt. I would have tempered my expectations, and this loss would have been slightly less frustrating. I am struggling to pull any positives from this game. To win this game the Minnesota needed to get home with pressure and not let Super Kamario beat you with his legs. They also needed to establish a run game to take time off the clock and give your defense a breather. Neither happened. Darius Taylor was hurt, and the Gophers managed 13 yards on the ground. Pressure on Super Kamario was non-existent as the Gophers managed 1 sack and Super Kamario had 80+ on the ground. Minnesota just looked unprepared and outmatched. Every year you get a game or two that just make you mad when watching the Gophers, and lucky for us we got that in week 2. Moving forward I am not out on Minnesota, but this was concerning nonetheless.
Iowa 16 Iowa State 13
This was the second and final game that a Big Ten team won vs a Power 4 opponent. The expectations for Iowa State this year are basically nonexistent just based on when they lost their coach, what they lost in the portal, and what they brought in from the portal. This is a rebuild year, a year that shouldn’t count against Jimmy Rogers. When you look at it like that, it made sense that Iowa was favored by nearly 2 touchdowns. But this is a rivalry game, and recent history has shown us that no matter how bad either side might be, this is always a close game. This year is no different. Iowa looked like nearly every Iowa team for the last decade. A mediocre offense, a good defense, and solid special teams. It really doesn’t concern me that the Hawkeyes only won this game by 3 points. This is exactly what we will probably see from Iowa all season long.
Wake Forest 38 Purdue 36 2OT
What a tough break for Purdue. They scored twice in the final 4 min of the game to force OT. They were up 36-30 in the 2nd OT and had Wake Forest facing a 4th&15. Wake Forest converts, scores a TD, and converts the 2 point conversion to win the game. Just a heartbreaking loss if you’re a Purdue fan. Former Gopher Fame Ijeboi had a great game with 114 on the ground, 42 receiving, and 3 touchdowns. While this is a game that they should’ve won, I think it bodes well for Purdue moving forward. I am by no means saying they are a good team right now, but I feel much more confident in my prediction that they will win at least 1 Big Ten game this season.
Duke 31 Illinois 27
My concern for Illinois going into this season was their ability to stop the run. Through 2 weeks, I am still very concerned. Nate Sheppard could not be stopped. Sheppard went off for 147 yards at just over 6 yards a carry. He also added another 40+ yards receiving and finished with 3 touchdowns. Duke took a 31-27 very early in the 4th quarter and Illinois had more than enough chances to win this game, but ultimately came up short. I was high on Illinois and low on Duke heading into the year, but I may have been off on both. I am more concerned with Illinois moving forward after watching their defense struggle to stop the run the first couple weeks of the season.
Boston College 28 Rutgers 21
Rutgers started off the terrible weekend for the Big Ten by losing to a team most people, including myself, considered to be one of the worst teams in all of college football. I was not high on Rutgers heading into the year as I thought it was possible Greg Schiano would not survive the season. Turns out it was way worse than I expected. Rutgers is easily one of the worst teams not only in the Power 4, but all of football. Just an absolutely pitiful performance in both games so far this season. KJ Duff has been phenomenal, Antwan Raymond has been fine, but everyone else on Rutgers have been terrible. The offense has turned the ball over 8 times in the first 2 weeks, and the defense has allowed around 400 yards of offense in each game. Greg Schiano may not survive through October.
Was this a great weekend for the Big Ten? Absolutely not. Far from it in fact. Is the Big Ten’s 3 year reign over? I am not going to say that yet. Indiana has yet to play a team with a pulse. Ohio State lost to Texas by 1 point. Oregon can still turn it around. USC hasn’t played anyone that scares you yet. The 3 year reign is far from over, but this weekend was definitely a slight concern. What do you think? Do you think the Big Ten’s reign is over?

I think it’s too soon to declare the Big Ten’s reign over. Yes, Ohio State and Oregon lost but I still think the National Championship has a respectable chance of staying in the Big Ten. Indiana is looking good, Ohio State will bounce back, and Oregon still has a ton of talent.
Agreed. Definitely too soon to officially call it. The Ohio State loss is not concerning to me. We still need to see Indiana and USC play teams with a pulse. With Oregon I’d like to see if they follow in the footsteps of Alabama from last year, or Penn State from last year. I tend to lean that we’ll see a significant bounce back from them.