Skip to content
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • X
  • YouTube
Just Win Minnesota Just Win Minnesota Just Win Minnesota

The Voice of Minnesota Sports Fans

Just Win Minnesota Just Win Minnesota Just Win Minnesota

The Voice of Minnesota Sports Fans

  • Just Win Minnesota Blog
    • Vikings
    • Timberwolves
    • Wild
    • Twins
    • Gophers
    • Lynx
    • Sports
    • Just Thinking
  • Podcast
  • Championship Drought Clock
  • About
    • About Just Win Minnesota
    • Meet The Team
  • Shop
  • Just Win Minnesota Blog
    • Vikings
    • Timberwolves
    • Wild
    • Twins
    • Gophers
    • Lynx
    • Sports
    • Just Thinking
  • Podcast
  • Championship Drought Clock
  • About
    • About Just Win Minnesota
    • Meet The Team
  • Shop
Gophers

The Gophers Loss to Mississippi State is the Most Inexcusable of the PJ Fleck Era

By Ben
September 14, 2026 4 Min Read
5

The Gophers were blown out at home against Mississippi State on Saturday, losing 38-13 at Huntington Bank Stadium. I’m writing this a couple of days later as I’ve been out of town for a friends wedding, but I’ve been stewing on some things from that loss over the past 48 hours.

Is Danny Collins Completely in Over His Head?

It’s the elephant in the room for fans who follow the Gopher program closely.

The most concerning part of the Mississippi State performance wasn’t simply that the defense played poorly. It was that they looked completely ill-prepared for what Mississippi State wanted to do. The Bulldogs seemed to have answers from the opening drive, while Minnesota spent most of the game searching for theirs.

And unfortunately, this isn’t the first time we’ve seen it.

There were similar warning signs in last year’s losses to Iowa and Northwestern, when the defense struggled badly and never seemed capable of making the adjustments necessary to stop the bleeding. One ugly defensive performance happens. Two can be written off. But when the same problems start carrying over from one season to the next, it becomes a trend—and that’s where my concern with Danny Collins really starts.

This is no longer just about players missing tackles or losing individual matchups. At times, this defense has looked like it simply wasn’t prepared for what was coming.

That falls on coaching.

If Minnesota continues having games where the defense looks this lost, the question won’t be whether Collins had a bad game plan. It’ll be whether he’s the right person to be making the game plan in the first place.

In 2018 P.J. Fleck fired Robb Smith mid-season after his defense game up 55 points to a bad Illinois team. That move sparked the Gophers to beat Wisconsin and make their first bowl game under Fleck.

I can’t help but wonder if the Gophers defense continues to struggle in the coming weeks if Danny Collins isn’t destined for the same fate as Robb Smith.

The Offense Wasn’t Much Better

The Gophers mustered up a total of six points on offense on Saturday. Drake Lindsey threw for 279 yards on 31/48 passing, but at times looked a little erratic and rattled.

But what was especially concerning is that the Gophers only rushed for 13 yards on Saturday. Yes, you read that right. 13 yards!

What’s especially concerning is that improving the run game was a major emphasis this past offseason for Offensive Coordinator Greg Harbaugh Jr.

The #Gophers ranked last in the B1G in 2025 in rushing offense. You know it. I know it, and so does offensive coordinator Greg Harbaugh.

He details the meticulous offseason plan to fix it, plus Fleck runs through some names to watch after Darius Taylor.https://t.co/usj8OpGnj8

— Ryan Burns (@RyanBurnsMN) March 24, 2026

This was the first major test this season for Greg Harbaugh Jr and his offense rushed the ball for 13 measly yards. Yes, I know Darius Taylor is hurt. However, with the right scheme and personnel, your backups should still be able to create an effective running game. Yet they still only rushed for 13 yards.

And the fact that the running game was the major emphasis of the offseason… yikes.

P.J. Fleck Seems Completely Aloof

The Gophers lost 38-13. They finished with 13 rushing yards, failed to score an offensive touchdown and watched Mississippi State score touchdowns on each of its first four possessions.

And yet, listening to Fleck on Monday, there was still this sense that he was relatively comfortable with what Minnesota had tried to do. He talked about how Mississippi State’s explosiveness took Minnesota out of its game plan pretty quickly and gave the Bulldogs plenty of credit for dictating the game.

He even said on Monday that he liked the Gophers’ game plan.

Maybe that’s coach-speak. Maybe he genuinely believes the plan was good and the execution was the problem. And to be fair, coaches obviously know significantly more about football than us fans sitting in our seats or watching on TV.

But their game plan produces 13 rushing yards and zero offensive touchdowns. I think we should be allowed to ask a few questions about the game plan.

Fleck also made sure to praise his team for playing hard until the final whistle, pointing to the late defensive touchdown and blocked kick as evidence that his players never quit. And sure, that’s admirable—but unfortunately for P.J., moral victories are not accepted here at Just Win Minnesota.

Playing hard until the end is the expectation. The final score is still the final score, and around here, the name of the website isn’t Just Compete Minnesota.

That’s what can be frustrating about Fleck’s press conferences. He rarely seems as bothered by these performances as the people watching them. There’s always a lesson or something they can learn from. He’s always giving credit to the opponent. There’s always something that was actually encouraging if you look closely enough.

I know it might be different behind closed doors in the team meeting, and I do get the feeling that P.J. is very defensive publicly of his team and he is especially sensitive to criticism.

And I don’t need him to flip over the podium at his press conferences. But occasionally it would be refreshing to hear something along the lines of, “Yeah, that was terrible.”

Instead, Fleck sometimes has an almost impressive ability to remain completely detached from the emotional reality of the fan base. And as the frustrating losses continue to pile up and the press conferences remain the same, it gets more and more frustrating for fans who are craving for the Gophers to be relevant nationally once again.

Share
error
fb-share-icon
Tweet
fb-share-icon

Tags:

gopher footballminnesota golden gopherspj fleck
Author

Ben

Follow Me
Other Articles
Previous

Is the Big Ten’s Three Year Reign Over?

Next

John Hynes Earned This Extension. Now Comes the Hard Part.

5 Comments
  1. Danny says:
    September 14, 2026 at 1:50 pm

    I had concerns about Collins ever since he was announced as the new defensive coordinator. I was not buying the whole narrative that he slept in the building on a cot and worked his way up from being a grad student assistant. My concern also is that PJ Fleck will not have the guts to fire Collins since he’s been with him since his days at Western Michigan. Minnesota lost the last two defensive coordinators to either more money or bigger better programs. I don’t have much hope if Collins stays the rest of the season. There’s way too much talent on the defense to be this unprepared and out coached we saw the same issues Gap protection and inability to tackle

    Reply
    1. Ben says:
      September 14, 2026 at 2:12 pm

      I think Fleck would fire him if it came to it. He fired Matt Simon last offseason who had been with him since Western Michigan as well. But I do think the U administration needs to invest more money into Fleck’s coaching staff so they can get higher quality coordinators. Imagine how much different thing might be if they had the money to keep Heathermann…

      Reply
  2. My Official Apology to Danny Collins - Just Win Minnesota says:
    October 3, 2026 at 10:33 pm

    […] After the Gophers’ defensive meltdown against Mississippi State, I was pretty critical of Minnesota’s defensive coordinator. Actually, “pretty critical” might be putting it nicely. I openly questioned whether Collins was in over his head. […]

    Reply
  3. Gophers vs. Purdue Prediction: Don't Let the Michigan Win Go to Waste - Just Win Minnesota says:
    October 8, 2026 at 10:32 pm

    […] Earlier in the season, I was openly questioning whether defensive coordinator Danny Coll… Now, after the performances against Washington and Michigan, I’m starting to wonder whether we have enough money to keep him after the season. […]

    Reply
  4. Dear P.J. Fleck, It's Time to Change Your Best - Just Win Minnesota says:
    October 11, 2026 at 9:45 pm

    […] Earlier this year, I declared the Gophers loss to Mississippi State the most inexcusable loss of the P.J. Fleck era. […]

    Reply
Show Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Ryan Jeffers Accepts The Twins Qualifying Offer
  • Predicting the CFP Rankings
  • The Minnesota Wild Have the Best Line in Hockey. But Is That Enough to Win a Stanley Cup?
  • College Football Playoff Rankings
  • Can Carson Wentz Save The Vikings Offense?

Recent Comments

  1. jakeybigs on Choosing the Perfect Jersey for a Vikings Fan on a Sunday
  2. Joe on Choosing the Perfect Jersey for a Vikings Fan on a Sunday
  3. Vikings Vibe Check Week 7: Game Preview, Bets, & Final Score Predictions - Just Win Minnesota on The Just Win Minnesota Official 2026 Minnesota Vikings Season Predictions
  4. Grading Gopher Football's First Half Of The Season and What To Expect In The Second Half - Just Win Minnesota on How Will The Gophers Fare For The 2026 Football Season? Ben’s Completely Unbiased Season Predictions
  5. SpudLover69 on Minnesota Wild Pulse Check After Five Games

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026

Categories

  • Frost
  • Gophers
  • Just Thinking
  • Lynx
  • Sports
  • Timberwolves
  • Twins
  • Uncategorized
  • Vikings
  • Wild
  • Ryan Jeffers Accepts The Twins Qualifying Offer
  • Predicting the CFP Rankings
  • The Minnesota Wild Have the Best Line in Hockey. But Is That Enough to Win a Stanley Cup?
  • College Football Playoff Rankings
  • Can Carson Wentz Save The Vikings Offense?
  • Frost
  • Gophers
  • Just Thinking
  • Lynx
  • Sports
  • Timberwolves
  • Twins
  • Uncategorized
  • Vikings
  • Wild
Copyright 2026 — Just Win Minnesota. All rights reserved. Blogsy WordPress Theme